13 Best Store-Bought Horseradish Sauces, Ranked

Arby's Horsey Sauce, ranked last, holds a modest position due to a specific reason: While it aims to capture the essence of the horseradish sauce found in Arby's renowned restaurants, its flavor profile falls flat, resulting in very little impact on the palate, aside from an overwhelming sweetness. Known for its creamy texture and milder rendition of horseradish, this sauce sparks intriguing debates among customers as to whether its bottled version truly captures the essence of the small packeted condiment that has become a staple in Arby's restaurants. 

The reviews from Walmart customers for the sauce are less than favorable. Some customers expressed disappointment, mentioning that it lacked spiciness and was too sweet. One customer specifically noted that it didn't have the same horseradish kick as the sauce in Arby's restaurants. Another reviewer even remarked that it tasted similar to plain mayo, with no kick whatsoever. These reviews indicate that the sauce did not meet the expectations or satisfy the preferences of customers. 

Kraft Horseradish Sauce, per Walmart's product page description, boasts a rejuvenating, spicy taste, although it still exhibits a slightly milder horseradish flavor. This sauce plays well with beef dishes, offering a zingy enhancement. Additionally, its versatility allows it to serve as a base for salad dressings or a creamy dipping sauce, further expanding its potential. However, this versatility comes at a cost. The horseradish flavor is noticeably subdued, and some find the sauce to taste more like mayo with just a hint of horseradish, preventing it from securing a higher ranking on this list.

Delighted Walmart customers have shared their experiences with one review expressing how they enjoy adding this sauce to tuna sandwich spreads, roast beef sandwiches, or grilled hamburgers, as it imparts some zing to enhance the chosen proteins. However, a more critical Amazon review speaks about the sauce tasting more like mayo rather than a horseradish sauce, leading to a decision not to repurchase it. 

Next on our list is Bookbinder's Creamy Horseradish Sauce. Per their website, the sauce goes beyond its traditional association with roast beef, showcases its versatility in various culinary applications such as adding zing to smoked fish and sandwiches. Crafted with fresh horseradish, the sauce strikes a balanced combination of creaminess and tartness, embodying the invigorating heat that horseradish enthusiasts appreciate. This sauce brings better flavor than lower ranked sauces on our list, but the zing is not quite there and therefore it has to stay in this position. While this sauce offers robust flavor compared to lower-ranked options, it lacks the distinctive zing that sets apart the top contenders, resulting in its placement at this position on our list.

Customers have expressed their admiration for Bookbinder's Creamy Horseradish Sauce. One satisfied Amazon shopper shares, "I love this sauce so much! Excellent in pork and any meat. Works well for me on a sandwich instead of mayo or mustard. Has a little kick but not overwhelming. Excellent flavor. I like the consistency." This testimony highlights the sauce's versatility and ability to enhance various meat dishes, offering an acceptable alternative to traditional condiments. Another review from a Walmart customer acknowledges the sauce's higher price but deems it worth it for the taste. 

Moving forward to Silver Springs Sauce Horseradish. This sauce is claimed on Silver Spring's official website as a unique combination of sinus-clearing effects akin to prepared horseradish, but with a milder and creamier profile. The absence of fillers and additional sweeteners, combined with its smooth consistency make it a perfect choice for spreading on sandwiches and blending into various sauces. While this high-quality sauce effectively captures excellent horseradish characteristics without any unwanted additions, its purist approach may not resonate with everyone, ultimately resulting in its placement in the middle of our list.

Satisfied customers testified on the distinct qualities of Silver Springs Sauce Horseradish. On Amazon, a reviewer describes it as a family staple during holiday pork loin dinners, highlighting its texture and punch. Another reviewer appreciates the simplicity of the ingredients, noting that it contains no fillers or excessive sweeteners, fats, or dairy with just the right amount of "bite" to make its presence known without overwhelming the senses. They recommend it as a finishing touch for steak, roast beef sandwiches, shrimp cocktail sauce, and even for sushi or sashimi enthusiasts who prefer a milder wasabi experience.

Individual preferences and expectations indeed vary. Hoping to find a condiment similar to Arby's Horsey Sauce, an Amazon shopper was taken aback by the intense spiciness of the product. They describe their experience as a fiery sensation that left them scrambling for a glass of milk.

Next on our list is Terrapin Ridge Farms Sriracha Horseradish Garnishing Sauce. According to their official site, this U.S.-made sauce brings together the bold flavors of Sriracha and Horseradish, delivering a one-two punch that adds excitement to gourmet sandwiches, wraps, and burgers. Its versatility extends beyond these dishes, making it an excellent dip for calamari, onion rings, and sweet potato fries, and a perfect addition to tuna salad, potato salad, and coleslaw. However, its consistency may be too thin for some individuals, leading to its placement in this position on our list.

Positive reviews from satisfied customers highlight the delightful qualities of this sauce. One Amazon reviewer, who enjoys adding a spicy touch to their meals, claims it to be the best among the 50 "hot" sauces they have tried. They appreciate the well-balanced blend of Sriracha and Horseradish, finding it suitable for sandwiches, hot dogs, fries, steaks, hamburgers, salads, and more. Another reviewer compares the sauce to Yum-yum sauce on steroids, praising its nice, gentle "kick." They mention trying it on a hamburger and enjoying the taste. They even suspect that their local sushi restaurant uses this sauce as a garnish for some of their sushi. However, one reviewer was looking forward to a sauce with evident horseradish and sriracha flavor and heat. They express disappointment, finding the sauce to be extremely thin and runny, which does not meet their expectations.

Taking the third spot on our list is the St. Elmo Steak House Creamy Horseradish, affectionately known as "Slammer Sauce" among grill cooks per their official site. This sauce combines a savory flavor with a kick of horseradish, making it a perfect complement to steaks and an even better choice for roast beef, ham, and other sandwiches. Crafted with zero artificial ingredients or preservatives, it delivers a powerful and refreshing taste. Moreover, it is worth noting that this horseradish sauce is gluten-free and certified kosher, catering to specific dietary preferences.

One satisfied reviewer confidently states that it is the only horseradish sauce worth buying. Another reviewer on Amazon, initially skeptical of jarred sauces, finds this one to be excellent, with a perfect balance of horseradish and creaminess. They note that its delicious flavor complements more than just steak. A less positive review expresses lack of heat and found this one to have only a slight burn and not the sought after intense sinus-clearing, eye-watering effects. However, they do acknowledge that it would make a good topping for burgers.

We have arrived at the pinnacle of our list: Atomic Horseradish – Extra Hot. This legendary sauce, proudly made in the USA, has been delighting taste buds for over 50 years, initially serving the discerning palate of the hospitality industry. As stated on its Amazon product page, Atomic Horseradish has earned a reputation as a hidden gem, establishing itself in upscale dining establishments without the need for paid advertisements. Now, you can enjoy the authentic experience of Atomic Horseradish firsthand from the comfort of your own home or kitchen.

Enthusiastic reviews showcase the sauce's exceptional qualities. One customer acknowledges its superiority compared to other alternatives, praising its flavorful profile and asserting that it delivers a satisfying bite, albeit not as hot as fresh horseradish. Another reviewer recalls discovering Atomic Horseradish during a visit to Las Vegas, where it was the go-to brand in all the renowned restaurants, and describes it as "hot and ... good!"

For the very last time, it is important to note that taste preferences can vary. A less enthusiastic reviewer expresses how they were hoping for an intensely hot horseradish experience that they did not find in Atomic Horseradish. Although highly regarded with positive reviews and a commendable flavor profile, Atomic Horseradish may not cater to the preferences of all individuals when it comes to heat and flavor intensity. Taste preferences vary, and those seeking a more intense or milder horseradish experience may find sauces ranked lower on this list better suited to their personal preferences.